Our baked delights
Discover the irresistible treats lovingly baked in our Staatsburg home kitchen. From classic cookies to festive cupcakes, each item is crafted with passion and the finest ingredients to bring a smile to your face.
Sweetest temptations, baked with love
At the Sweetest Little Cottage Bakery, we pour our heart into every single treat. Our homemade cookies, cupcakes, brownies, muffins, and Rice Krispie treats are made with quality ingredients, ensuring a truly delightful experience. You'll love our fan favorites like the classic chocolate chip cookies, vibrant rainbow Rice Krispie treats, and the ever-popular vanilla cupcakes with sprinkles. Each bite promises a taste of homemade happiness, crafted right here in Staatsburg, New York.
Perfect for every occasion
Whether you're planning a party, looking for a thoughtful gift, or simply craving an everyday treat, our baked goods are available by the dozen. We believe in providing generously sized portions of joy! Keep an eye out for our special seasonal items, especially during the festive period from Thanksgiving to Christmas. These limited-time offerings are perfect for adding a touch of holiday magic to your celebrations. While we're looking forward to joining local farmers markets and fairs soon, you can currently place your orders by emailing us at [[Sweetestlittlecottagebakery@gmail.com]].
By the dozen
Cookies
Chocolate Chip Cookies- $10
Made with brown butter and packed with chocolate chips, these are an everyday favorite for kids and kids at heart.
Brown Sugar Cookies- $9
A sweet, soft cookie with a rich taste.
Snowballs - $12
Soft, crumbly, and filled with freshly toasted pecans, then rolled in powdered sugar.
Chocolate Crinkle Cookies - $10
Soft, chewy, chocolatey, and rolled in powdered sugar. Enough said.
Snickerdoodle Cookies - $10
Soft, golden, and rolled in cinnamon sugar. A favorite amongst friends.
Peanut Butter Cookies- $8
Peanut buttery goodness baked until golden brown.
Peanut Butter Blossoms - $10
See above, then imagine that topped with a chocolate kiss.
Oatmeal Raisin Cookies - $10
Soft, sweet, cinnamon perfection. Raisins optional.
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies - $10
Why add chocolate chips to our awesome oatmeal cookies? Because we can.
Oatmeal Butterscotch Chip Cookies - $10
We can do this too.
Orange Sunrise Cookies - $10
Made with fresh orange zest and topped with a sweet glaze.
Molasses Cookies - $10
Old fashioned cookies to fill you with sweet nostalgia.
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies - $12
Jam packed with white chocolate chips and freshly toasted macadamia nuts.
Black and White Mini Cookies - $20
Well, technically they are brown and white, as we try not to add unnecessary dyes. This NYC specialty is one we love to share with family...sometimes.
Sugar and Spritz Cookies - $8 base price
Sugar and Spritz cookies are a timeless classic. But that's not why we love them so much. We can add colors, glazes, flavors, and sprinkles to create unique cookies. Just let us know how you like them!
Scones
Plain Scones - $11
Simple, mildly sweet, and an excellent addition to morning tea.
Chocolate Chip Scones - $15
Because chocolate chips can go with *almost* anything.
Cranberry Orange Scones - $15
Made with fresh orange zest and cranberries.
Raisin Scones - $14
Best when served warm with jam or clotted cream.
Cinnamon Sugar - $12
A little sweeter than normal and filled with cinnamon to give you that warm, fuzzy feeling.
Lemon Glazed - $14
Made with fresh lemon zest and juice, these are a great pick-me-up for the morning when you're on the go.
Maple Pecan - $20
Made with freshly toasted pecans and real Vermont maple syrup. There are no words, only sweet sighs of contentment.
Rice Treats
Plain Rice Treats - $10
The classic treat that will never go out of style.
Chocolate Rice Treats - $10
Because they make rice cereal in chocolate, we had to make these. We HAD to.
Rainbow Rice Treats - $10
Made with fruity rice cereal. Warning: do not leave these alone, they will disappear!
Maple Rice Treats - $14
Made with real Vermont maple syrup!
Cupcakes
Vanilla Cupcakes - $18
Classic vanilla, topped with vanilla or chocolate frosting.
Chocolate Cupcakes - $18
Delicious chocolate cupcakes, topped with vanilla or chocolate frosting.
Lemon Cupcakes - $19
Sweet cupcakes made with real lemon juice and fresh zest.
Muffins
Chocolate Chip Muffins - $14
Soft muffins with semi-sweet chocolate chips.
Cinnamon Sugar Muffins - $14
We've added a few heaping teaspoons of cinnamon to our muffins and topped them with course sugar.
Cranberry Orange Muffins - $14
Made with fresh orange zest, orange juice, and cranberries.
Maple Pecan Muffins - $18
Made with freshly toasted pecans and real Vermont maple syrup.